
The most powerful word Brian Rolapp, the CEO of the PGA Tour, used late Monday afternoon while talking to reporters in a remote press conference was simple. Well, two longer forms of it, more precisely: simplify and simplification. The occasion was the announcement of the concluding work, conducted over the past 18 months, by the Tour’s Future Competition Committee, chaired by Tiger Woods, who was not present for this confab powered by . . . Microsoft Teams, the preferred video conferencing service of the PGA Tour.
“We have seen the success of PGA Tour University across the PGA Tour system and it will now serve as the basis of eligibility on the Korn Ferry Tour,” Rolapp said at the start, reading from prepared remarks. “From the outset, we said we wanted to simplify the model and ensure there was a clear path for top performers at every stage of their career.”
I’m drawn to the word, because the world is complicated and golf is simple, or it should be. What is golf but an ancient overland game requiring its players to bat a small ball toward and into an annoyingly small hole with specified equipment, playing, all the while, your ball as it lies, the first and most essential rule that coexists with various others?
The play conducted by PGA Tour players is essentially simple. It aggregates the adventures of a group of men who are “chasing a little white ball” (per Rory McIlroy, repeatedly). The players count strokes. They count their own shots played, while counting the shots played by others, too. A two-way check. (Can you imagine tax returns if any of us could audit anybody we wished?) In theory, any and all golfers, male or female or otherwise, can play their way onto the PGA Tour. All you have to do is shoot the scores. In a manner of speaking and in a far more specific context, Rolapp was saying that very thing. He was summarizing the work of the Future Competition Committee.
Rolapp concluded his prepared remarks with this:
“Before I open up to questions, I will briefly address LIV because I suspect it might come up today. We have heard from our fans and we know that they want the best players playing together and we share that view. I have said that from day one when I took the job I am interested in doing whatever makes the PGA Tour better. That said, as we have a membership organization, we have rules, and as I shared before, they exist to ensure fairness and competitive balance. Rules matter and they will be enforced.”
Rules matter and they will be enforced.
Any competition committee at any level can run with that sentence.
I used to play in a fall golf event where you couldn’t make more than a triple bogey on any hole. It was a rule, a generous one, you could say, aimed at speeding up the pace of play for the field while keeping hope alive for individual players.
The LPGA recently announced new rules for 2027 aimed at improving the pace of play. When it’s your turn, you have to play your shot within 60 seconds. The clock is ticking. Six seconds too long will cost you a shot. Sixteen seconds too long will cost you two. Rules matter and they will be enforced. You can only hope that is a statement that applies across the game, wherever it is played.
The rules that govern play on the PGA Tour are not decided by its Future Competition Committee. But all golf competitions, including this week’s event at Sea Island, in the Georgia Lowcountry and hosted by a local, Davis Love III, start with its rules. One of the greatest insights I ever got about how to view the role of the rules in golf came from Davis, years ago. We were talking about how TV viewers could call in possible rules violations they observed. “It’s not like you’re trying to get away with anything,” Love said, “so why wouldn’t you want all the help you can to turn in the most accurate scorecard possible?” Flawless logic.
The first page of the rulebook instructs golfers to play the course as you find it and to play your ball as it lies. Bryson DeChambeau was penalized at the British Open at Royal Birkdale this year because he didn’t do that. In a manner of speaking, a viewer picked up on that: a rules official watching on TV. The official saw DeChambeau taking heavy-footed steps in the rough behind his ball in the rough of the fifth hole in the second round, thereby improving his lie. I couldn’t see it, watching the TV replays, but people with far more experience than I, including Rory McIlroy watching in real time, could. The Open’s competition committee gave DeChambeau two shots. He had failed to play his ball from its original lie.
Earlier this month, McIlroy received a two-shot penalty in the first round of the Abu Dhabi Aldar Championship, a DP World Tour event, for violating the same rule in a different way. On the 12th hole, with the flange of his sand wedge, he pressed too firmly into the grass behind his ball. The rule permits you to press “lightly,” letting a player rest the club with its actual weight but not apply his or her own force. In layman’s terms, you can’t shove your clubhead behind the ball.
In my casual golf, I almost never see anybody violate this rule, in spirit or in fact. Jack Nicklaus never did, because he always hovered his club over the ball when it was in a grassy lie. Watching a replay of the McIlroy situation, I could not readily see an issue. A rules official, watching on TV, could — or eventually could. A small tuft of grass that had been immediately behind McIlroy’s ball no longer was. He had changed his lie by being too aggressive while preparing to play his shot.
It’s a problem in pro golf. You can see similar situations often, whether you’re watching on TV or at a tournament in person. Typically, these movements go unchecked. It raises questions that get to the heart of the game, the game at its essential and simple core. Rolapp was asked about the McIlroy ruling, and the rule in general, in his virtual press conference on Monday afternoon. Rolapp, not a rules expert, deferred to one his deputies, Tyler Dennis, the Tour’s chief competitions officer, to address the question.
“I don’t want to comment on something that happened on the DP World Tour,” Dennis said. “But, just at kind of a high level, over the last few years we spent a lot of energy looking through the entire set of rules, and the things that happen on Tour, going [toward] simplification. We’ve made tons of improvements to clarify those type of things and also, frankly, to address a lot of inequities or perceived injustices. We feel great with where the rules are right now, and our officials are always focused and working closely with the USGA and R&A on the things that we can improve.”
Dennis was asked to be more specific: What can a player do when addressing his ball without touching it or improving his lie?
“Our officials are, honestly, really the experts on this,” Dennis said. “But I can just tell you that on that particular rule, we feel very confident about how it’s written and how it’s applied each week, and the fairness and outcomes we’re seeing.”
It’s funny: These salaried officials are experts; they understand the technical aspects of all of golf’s rules. But how they apply their expertise is another matter. We’ve all seen it. Moreover, they don’t see everything nor are they expected to. As for the players they don’t have to experts on the technical aspects of the rules. They have to know what you can and cannot do.
When the rulebook allows the player to touch “lightly,” it is permitting the player to use the weight of the clubhead when taking a stance and addressing the ball, and not more. Where’s the line? Again, the players are not technical experts. But they should be like Potter Stewart, the late Supreme Court justice, who said he had a hard time defining pornography “but I know it when I see it.” You put your clubhead behind your ball and in the grass. Did you do so lightly? You should know. Did a tuft of grass move along the way? Maybe it did and maybe it didn’t, and maybe you are aware and maybe you are not. But if were truly light with your touch, it’s unlikely
Anyway, and as per usual, Nicklaus, had the right idea. Just hover. His method was foolproof.
Michael Bamberger welcomes your comments at Michael.Bamberger@Golf.com